Our approach

Evaluation should change a decision — not decorate a dashboard

We start with the decision your team needs to make, then build the smallest credible body of evidence that can support it.

That means examining what the agent did step by step, testing judge agreement, controlling for the evaluation environment, and being explicit about what the results cannot prove.

Input The decision, your traces, and the failures that matter

Output Evidence your team can act on — not one opaque quality score

01 From question to evidence

A decision-led evaluation, in four stages

The method changes with the agent. The sequence does not.

  1. Frame

    Name the decision

    Ship or hold? Switch models or stay? Fix reliability or reduce cost? We start with the choice the evidence must support, then work backward to the evaluation.

    Working outputA decision statement and success criteria

  2. Define

    Define observable quality

    We translate “good” into checks that can be applied to your traces: groundedness, efficiency, recovery from failure, goal alignment, or criteria specific to your workflow.

    Working outputA metric set tied to actual failure modes

  3. Calibrate

    Build and calibrate the evidence

    We score real or representative traces, use multiple independent judges where appropriate, and surface disagreement instead of hiding it inside an average.

    Working outputScored traces and a focused human-review queue

  4. Decide

    Compare, diagnose, decide

    We separate quality, cost, and speed; identify the steps where failures begin; and report what the evidence supports — including where it remains inconclusive.

    Working outputTrade-offs, named defects, and next actions

02 Evidence controls

Three ways agent evaluation can mislead you

Our methodology is designed around the failure modes of the evaluation itself.

Failure modeA plausible final answer hides a broken process.

Our response

Judge the trajectory, not just the answer

Agents fail in the middle: fabricated tool arguments, redundant calls, and errors quietly ignored. We evaluate each observable action in context, then connect those step-level findings to the final outcome.

Failure modeOne automated judge sounds certain but is wrong.

Our response

Trust a judge only as far as agreement allows

A single LLM judge can be noisy, systematically strict, or systematically lenient. We use judges from different providers, report where they agree, and route consequential disagreements to human review.

Failure modeThe evaluation measures the test setup instead of the agent.

Our response

Measure the agent, not the environment

Empty test data, changed software versions, and replay artifacts can distort results. We check comparability before reporting a number and separate conclusions that cannot support a clean comparison.

03 Working principles

Credibility depends on what we refuse to obscure

Useful evaluation distinguishes measured facts, informed interpretation, and open questions.

  1. Be honest about limits

    Every report states what was not measured, which conclusions need an asterisk, and what evidence would make the result stronger.

  2. Stay vendor-neutral

    We don't sell a platform or earn from your tooling choices. We work with the stack you have and recommend changes only when the evidence supports them.

  3. Keep your data yours

    We're happy to work under NDA, inside your environment, with the minimum data access the evaluation needs.

What decision does your evaluation need to support?

Tell us about the agent, the evidence you already have, and the choice your team is facing.

Get in touch